MRCPsychLog in
Back to topics

Read this topic

Behavioural Science & Sociocultural Psychiatry · Paper A

Schedules of reinforcement

The idea

Schedules of reinforcement matter because HOW OFTEN a reward is given, not just whether it is given, changes how strongly and how persistently a behaviour is learned. Continuous reinforcement rewards every single correct response, while partial (intermittent) reinforcement rewards only some responses. For example, imagine training a dog to sit: rewarding every single sit teaches the behaviour fastest, but rewarding it only sometimes makes the dog keep trying for far longer once rewards stop.

How it works

Reinforcement schedules combine two dimensions: fixed vs variable (how predictable the reward timing is) and ratio vs interval (whether reward depends on the NUMBER of responses or the TIME elapsed). A fixed-ratio schedule rewards after a set number of responses, e.g. a piece-rate factory worker paid every tenth item. A variable-ratio schedule rewards after an unpredictable number of responses, e.g. a slot machine that pays out on an unpredictable spin. A fixed-interval schedule rewards the first response after a set time, e.g. checking the post once a day. A variable-interval schedule rewards the first response after an unpredictable time, e.g. refreshing a page for a random notification. For example, imagine a gambler who keeps playing a slot machine for hours, that persistence reflects a variable-ratio schedule, the type that produces the highest, steadiest response rate. In practice, this means gambling behaviour is so hard to extinguish precisely because it runs on a variable-ratio schedule, not because of any special property of money itself.

How to spot it

  • A trainer moves a dog from treats every time to occasional treats, and finds the behaviour becomes much harder to extinguish. What is this phenomenon called?
  • A researcher plots cumulative responses over time and sees a steady, moderate rate with no post-reward pauses and no scalloping. Which schedule produces this pattern?
  • A child's tantrums are ignored most of the time, but a parent occasionally gives in when especially tired. Which schedule is inadvertently being used, and with what consequence?
  • A token economy on a rehabilitation ward gives tokens exchangeable for privileges. What is the correct term for the tokens themselves in learning theory?

Tell it apart

  • Variable-ratio schedule, reward after an unpredictable number of responses, unlike fixed-ratio, which rewards after a set, predictable number of responses.
  • Fixed-interval schedule, reward for the first response after a set time, whereas variable-interval rewards the first response after an unpredictable time.
  • Partial reinforcement, only some responses are rewarded, rather than continuous reinforcement, which rewards every single response and is learned fastest but extinguishes quickest.
  • Schedules of reinforcement, how OFTEN an already-learned response is rewarded, unlike shaping, which reinforces successive approximations toward a brand-new target behaviour.

Watch for

  • That schedule produces a very high steady rate rather than moderate.
  • That arrangement rewards every response rather than intermittently.
  • That effect concerns reward displacing internal motivation.
  • That describes a response reappearing after a rest interval.
  • That describes responding to stimuli similar to the trained one.

Use it again

  • Name the learning, social or research principle being tested before reading the options.
  • Identify the antecedent, behaviour, consequence or cognitive process in the vignette.
  • Compare the direction of effect with the nearest competing principle.
  • Apply the same rule to a new example to confirm that the answer transfers.

Try a question from this area

  • Question 1
  • Question 2
  • Question 3